Mystic Fish

My daughter came back from LA and wanted to go out to find a restaurant for dinner, and asked Chatgpt that the first place was this one. We didn't make a reservation, and it was crowded with dinner time on Monday. Their dishes and plates are very good. Their vegetables are also fresh and delicious.

Wonderful experience! The service and food were exceptional. The portions were perfect and worth the price. We celebrated a birthday and the waitress helped make sure it was a perfect evening. We will definitely return!

Tampa Bay Food Tours is sharing a local favorite that is a mainstay for a reason! Mystic Fish in Palm Harbor never disappoints. The photos featured are from their infamous early dinner specials—huge portions, beautifully prepared, and at truly amazing prices. The quality, freshness, and presentation feel upscale, but the value makes it approachable and perfect for locals and visitors alike. Consistently delicious seafood, great service, and a welcoming atmosphere. If you haven’t tried the early dinner, you’re missing out! Visit soon and tell them Tampa Bay Food Tours sent you.

My husband and I sat at the bar and had a couple of appetizers and drinks. The bartender was welcoming and friendly. The ambience was cozy and serene, the food was well presented and absolutely delicious. We had the Grilled Octopus, Ahi Tuna, Raw Oysters, and Key Lime Panna Cotta. The cocktail, Blackbeard’s Delight, which was a mixture of Plantation Rum, Lime, Banana & Blackberry was deliciously tasteful.

We just celebrated a friends 80th birthday at Mystic Fish. There were 16 in attendance and everyone agreed it was an extraordinary evening. Our servers Steven and Joe were the epitome of customer service. Our every need was anticipated and acted upon immediately. All 16 meals were brought to the table at once, piping hot. The early specials and the main menu meals were spectacular. There was no waiting for a refresh of our craft cocktails and wine selections. The staff did everything possible to make this a memorable 80th birthday celebration and we are all very grateful.