Situated in a chamring old house that creaks with nostalgia, Cappy's Pizzeria serves up New York style and Chicago style pies, with toppings that include anchovies, feta, bacon, broccoli, pepperoncini, pineapple, artichoke hearts and more. The beer comes in mason jars, which ups the hipster factor. Split a large Greek salad among the table topped with potato salad and Cappy's dressing.

Hours

Monday 5 PM–9 PM

Tuesday 5 PM–9 PM

Wednesday 5 PM–9 PM

Thursday 5 PM–9 PM

Friday 5 PM–10 PM

Saturday 5 PM–10 PM

Sunday 5 PM–9 PM

What Visitors Love

Kyle Ames

3 weeks ago

Loved the pizza! I wouldn't call it a true deep dish but it was still delicious! You can build your own pizza with toppings but their standards they have on the menu were the Cappy which is essentially meat lovers/supreme or the veggie or cheese. We built our own and made up a Hawaiian pizza with bacon, jalapeno, pineapple and chicken. Really enjoyed the dangling lights to sit out under on the patio and watch traffic go by.

Kerrie Blankenship

3 months ago

Happy I finally tried cappy’s! This pizza house gives all the nostalgic classic pizza place charm whether is casual dinner with family or want your fairly inexpensive pizza with a friend! Inside had fun cool booths and lovely atmosphere with super personable staff. We came for dinner on a Saturday night, and ordered a small Cesar salad (perfect for 2-3 people) and a half cheese half pepperoni NY style pizza. Make sure you sample some the local brews on tap or grab something out of the self serve fridge while you wait for a table. Also a notable cute touch is they give you a piece of bubblegum with your check! Everything is exactly what I wanted for a pizza dinner and it was cozy nostalgic vibes- definitely worthy of a visit!

Ovi

3 months ago

Cappy’s in St. Pete is one of those places that reminds you why great pizza never goes out of style. Their pies come out perfect — crisp crust, balanced toppings, and that unmistakable Cappy’s flavor that keeps you thinking about your next visit before you’ve even left. The staff is just as impressive. Everyone is friendly, welcoming, and genuinely happy to help, which makes the whole experience feel easy and relaxed. It’s the kind of spot you recommend with confidence because you know they deliver every single time.

Preston Coffin

a week ago

This is my favorite pizza in St Pete - awesome, easy-going atmosphere and excellent food. Super friendly service as well, Rob is the man!!!

Dave C

6 months ago

Deep dish pizza and Greek salad were really good! Also the garlic bread! Two of us barely made a dent and took a whole box of food home with us. And. Rob was a great waiter!

View all Google Reviews

Accessible Features

  • Wheelchair Accessible Entrance
  • Wheelchair Accessible Parking
  • Wheelchair Accessible Restroom