Situated in a chamring old house that creaks with nostalgia, Cappy's Pizzeria serves up New York style and Chicago style pies, with toppings that include anchovies, feta, bacon, broccoli, pepperoncini, pineapple, artichoke hearts and more. The beer comes in mason jars, which ups the hipster factor. Split a large Greek salad among the table topped with potato salad and Cappy's dressing.

Hours

Monday 5 PM–9 PM

Tuesday 5 PM–9 PM

Wednesday 5 PM–9 PM

Thursday 5 PM–9 PM

Friday 5 PM–10 PM

Saturday 5 PM–10 PM

Sunday 5 PM–9 PM

Guest Reviews

Kerrie Blankenship

3 weeks ago

Happy I finally tried cappy’s! This pizza house gives all the nostalgic classic pizza place charm whether is casual dinner with family or want your fairly inexpensive pizza with a friend! Inside had fun cool booths and lovely atmosphere with super personable staff. We came for dinner on a Saturday night, and ordered a small Cesar salad (perfect for 2-3 people) and a half cheese half pepperoni NY style pizza. Make sure you sample some the local brews on tap or grab something out of the self serve fridge while you wait for a table. Also a notable cute touch is they give you a piece of bubblegum with your check! Everything is exactly what I wanted for a pizza dinner and it was cozy nostalgic vibes- definitely worthy of a visit!

Deirdre Smith

6 months ago

Absolutely delicious pizza! Had to knock off some of the flour, but other than that it was delicious. Our server Rob was amazing! The 16' large was perfect for two.

Jennifer Boker

5 months ago

Good was amazing! Great Chicago Style and New York Style pizza, calzones and the Greek salad and cheesy breadsticks are great! Family friendly and parking is decent. Calm atmosphere with trivia cards at the tables inside and outside patio is my favorite. Come try it out!

Olivia Drevalas

a week ago

Our neighborhood pizza place! Ate here for the first time tonight and it was so good! Our server was a girl with dark hair I can’t remember her name but she was amazing, and made sure we had everything we needed. Can not wait to go back.

Dave C

3 months ago

Deep dish pizza and Greek salad were really good! Also the garlic bread! Two of us barely made a dent and took a whole box of food home with us. And. Rob was a great waiter!

Accessible Features

  • Wheelchair Accessible Entrance
  • Wheelchair Accessible Parking
  • Wheelchair Accessible Restroom