Dining in Treasure Island

Dining in Treasure Island

Nestled along the Gulf Coast of Florida, the barrier island known as Treasure Island offers a pleasant mix of sun, sand and satisfying eats. The atmosphere leans toward casual‑beach comfort — think fresh seafood shacks, burgers with unique toppings and laid‑back patios where the ocean breeze is also on the menu.

Sensational Seafood

Many eateries specialize in Gulf‑fresh fish, shrimp, oysters and hearty coastal fare, served either right on the beach or just steps from it. If you’re on the hunt for the best seafood in town, the grouper sandwich from Caddy’s Treasure Island is a good bet. If you’re looking for a mix of upbeat vibe, drink specials and seafood served with a side of fun, consider Ricky T’s Bar and Grille. For a more elevated dining experience try Middle Grounds Grill — known for its expertly prepared grouper, seafood risotto and fresh tuna.

Beach Bites & Brews

If you’re looking to kick back with a cold beer and some casual bites on the sand, you’re in luck! Several spots on the island provide relaxed beach vibes, yummy food and refreshing drink offerings. For classic beachside treats, you can't beat Sloppy Joe's on the Beach at the Bilmar Beach Resort. The vibe is casual, beach‑chic and fun, perfect for families by day and casual barflies at night. For a good ol’ burger, there’s no better place to go than BRGR Kitchen & Bar. If you’re hoping to round out your night with a cold beer, Sea Dog Brewing Co. is the place to go.

International Flair

The island’s dining scene offers a surprisingly global spread—from old‑world Italian to bold Tex‑Mex‑inspired flavors—all within easy reach of beach views. For delicious handhelds, like a classic Cuban or a flavorful spiced pork sandwich, head to The Floridian Cuban Sandwiches. For a taste of Italy, check out Gigi’s Italian Restaurant. This family‑run spot has been serving the island since 1967, offering from scratch pasta dishes and wood‑fired pizzas in a cozy candle‑lit setting. Head to VIP Mexican Restaurant & Lounge, a local landmark that delivers authentic Mexican‑style dishes, Tex‑Mex favorites and inventive creations and tasty margaritas.