Madison Avenue Pizza

We stopped, checked the place out (in person and online), Looked good and sounded good, so we ordered takeout for our daytrip to Honeymoon Island. We ordered Mottzerella Sticks, 12 Garlic Knots and a Meatlovers Calzone (minus the ham and added meatball). The MottzSticks are loaded with cheese and fried crispy, the garlic knots are large, fluffy, garlicy and soft, and the calzone was fat and loaded with goodness! The damage was $54.54 but the smiles ran 10/10!! Awesome and recommend.... next time we gettin that 32" pie!

Worth drive to have delicious food! Pizza fabulous! Steak sandwich with tots! Yummy Garlic knots! Delicious Mozzarella sticks! The best! Thanks for great service and fresh delicious food!

I just discovered the greatest Pizza spot, a real gem in Northern Pinellas! From the second you walk in, the vibes are vibing. The staff is incredibly friendly, the music keeps the energy up, and the whole place just has a great atmosphere. To top it off, the drinks were totally hitting the spot, and very reasonably priced. The spicy blackberry margarita was incredible. Bonus points: they even have an old-school Ms. Pac-Man machine to play while you wait! 🕹️ We started with salads that were fresh and of a good portion, the housemade dressing was delish. I love a good, well-done Brick Oven Pizza, and the crust was nicely done but not overly done - it was just right, and the best toppings (we did half meatball, all over onion, peppers and I added long hots too. We ordered the Old School cheese pie, which they let rise for 96 hours to develop that signature New York bite. Man, it was crisp, no flop, and just enough tang to eat every bite. Took me back to my favs in NYC for real. They deliver around Dunedin and Palm Harbor. If you’re looking for phenomenal pizza, great drinks, and a fun environment, this is your new go-to in the north County. The owners were present and care about quality too. Shout out to Ben the best server. We will definitely be back.

Loved Maddison Avenue Pizza! The atmosphere and décor are great, and the staff is super friendly. Tons of creative pizza options, including cauliflower crust, which I really appreciated. It’s awesome that almost everything is made in-house, even the chicken nuggets. Everything tasted fresh and delicious. I’ll definitely be going back! 🍕😊

Overall this is a good place for food & drinks. The pizza is good. It is a hand toss style pizza with a an average sauce and crust. If you like cupped style pepperoni they have it and also have regular pepperoni. The drinks were good, they have a variety of beers, menu prices are average. The MEATBALLS really are better than average and are LEGIT handmade NOT frozen mass production meatballs! The staff was friendly, helpful, and on point.